General News
20 November, 2026
Pastor's Ponderings: Replacement theology lacks basis
There's a term used from time to time in church circles: "replacement theology".

There's a term used from time to time in church circles: "replacement theology".
Also known as "supersessionism", it first reared its ugly head as far back as the 2nd century AD.
Sadly, it remains a major concern today and can, to a large degree, be seen as one of the foundational causes of much of the antisemitism that plagues our world.
Replacement theology is a false theological position which broadly holds that the Christian church has replaced Israel as the people of God in terms of biblical covenant and promise.
In its simplest form, the argument rests on five premises:
- God originally chose Israel to be His covenant people
- Israel rejected Jesus as the Messiah
- the Old Covenant was replaced by the New Covenant through Christ
- the Christian church became the new people of God
- the promises and blessings originally made to Israel are now applied to and fulfilled by the church, with some arguing that Israel no longer has any place in God's purposes.
Consequently, this idea has, over the centuries, become a vehicle for hatred and disdain towards Israel and its people.
Without doubt, it has been a significant factor in the growth of antisemitism, including within some ‘Christian’ churches around the world which, frankly, should know better.
The main theological fault with this argument lies in premise number three: that the Old Covenant was replaced by the New.
In fact, there was not just one ‘Old Covenant’ but four distinct covenants: the Noahic, the Abrahamic, the Mosaic and the Davidic.
The Noahic covenant was God's promise to never again destroy the earth with a flood.
The Abrahamic covenant was an unconditional promise that Abraham would become the father of many descendants, that his offspring would be given a land of their own and that through him all nations would be blessed.
The Mosaic covenant involved the giving of the Law, with blessings for obedience and curses for disobedience.
The Davidic covenant was God's promise that one of David's descendants would reign forever as king.
Christians understand this to be a reference to Christ.
So, we are faced with the question: when the ‘Old Covenant’ was discontinued, which one was it?
The answer is the Mosaic covenant.
When Christ died on the cross as the sacrifice to pay the penalty for the sins of all who would accept Him, the sacrificial system and the requirement to strictly follow Old Testament laws as the means of obtaining salvation were done away with and replaced by the New Covenant established through Christ.
But what about the other covenants?
This is the crucial issue so often overlooked by those advocating replacement theology.
The critical matter here is the Abrahamic covenant.
In Genesis 12:1–3, God said to Abraham:
“Go from your country, your people and your father's household to the land I will show you.
"I will make you into a great nation, and I will bless you; I will make your name great, and you will be a blessing.
"I will bless those who bless you, and whoever curses you I will curse; and all peoples on earth will be blessed through you.”
Notice that this promise to Abraham and his descendants is both unconditional and perpetual, meaning that it continues to this day and beyond.
Did the Jewish people reject Jesus, their Messiah and Saviour?
Absolutely, yes.
But that does not mean God has rejected them, any more than He rejects us.
Israel and its people will always remain a significant part of God's plan and purpose, not
because the Jewish people have always been faithful to Him but because God is, and will always be, faithful to His promise to them through Abraham.
Antisemitism, sadly all too common in our world today, is an ugly monster and no false or irrational excuse can ever justify it.
It is not an expression of love for anyone, but rather the outward expression of inward, irrational hatred, and it is responsible for so much of the violence and bloodshed we see throughout the world.
We need to remember the words of the Apostle John in 1 John 4:8: “Anyone who does not love does not know God, because God is love.”